| Advertisement | ![]() |
Click to advertise with us! |
@Helen , I know you mentioned this 16 years ago. I have had good luck with the Rico Graftonite B5's on my soprano and baritone saxes. They have sufficient penetration, and on my early 1950's Beaugnier Vito Low Bb baritone made it a joy to play, ditto with my sop.Yes Terry, do give the bari piece a try. I too was a devout Berg user on bari, and then I tried a Rico Graftonite... It was amazing. I then had the chance to get a new-old-stock Metalite and wow! It turned my Mark VI into a screaming rock horn.
For me (remember I'm a rock player on bari) the biggest problem has always been that the Bergs tend to "break" when pushed too hard. The Rico mouthpieces just don't do that. None of the notes break when you force a lot of air through the horn for maximum volume. What you do lose with the Ricos, is some of the lushness that the Bergs are known for.
Recently I bought a couple Metalite mouthpieces, they are the next for me to try.For jazz I still use my Berg hard rubber. For R&B I have a Berg stainless steel. For rock I use a Metalite. YMMV of course, and probably will.
The Metalite is versatile enough that it can be used for many applications, but for a true section sound, it will probably not blend very well (unless the other sax players are using them of course).
The Graftonite is a very good mouthpiece in its own right, and is very under-rated. I have a couple of them, and use them for a variety settings still.
@Helen , I know you mentioned this 16 years ago. I have had good luck with the Rico Graftonite B5's on my soprano and baritone saxes. They have sufficient penetration, and on my early 1950's Beaugnier Vito Low Bb baritone made it a joy to play, ditto with my sop.
Recently I found an available B5 for my tenor, and with a #2 Rico Jazz Select reed found that it also worked well with it.
Yet on other saxophone forums seems to be a real hate for any expression of truth regarding using these Graftonites and even Metalites. I got comments like, "Stop wasting your money on cheep mouthpieces, go spend a couple hundred dollars for a real mouthpiece and go practice with that".
With exception of this forum and the Saxophone Museum, I'm giving up on forums. It is difficult to have a simple, objective discussion, unfortunately.
Recently I bought a couple Metalite mouthpieces, they are the next for me to try.
You are welcome, Helen. This is why I enjoy WF and also why I was glad to find your posts giving a truthful assessment of the Rico's.Hey there ghostler, thank you! The staff at the WF try to keep this a friendly and helpful place full of knowledgeable, and helpful people.![]()
That is basically the issue in a nutshell, which also contributed to me closing my SOTW account.If you carefully look at who is saying what on forums, it's more often than not people who knowabout the topic they're talking about. Keyboard warriors about many topics, experts on none. There are lots of really knowledgeable people still on places like SOTW, but many of them have also left b/c of exactly what you mention. I stopped frequenting the site years ago. I still pop in from time to time, but long gone are the days of me spending hours talking with the people on there.
I gravitated to CS two years ago. However, the same SOTW gang frequent CS with the sameI do appreciate Cafe Saxophone more, b/c the crowd is much more civil. That's where many players have landed over the years.
Yup, the same false mantras.As far as the Rico Metalite and Graftonite MP goes, they have always had their detractors. People have long held the belief that the more $$$$ you spend on a MP, the better you'll sound.![]()


True, it's their money. I've finally come to the conclusion that I am better off helping the upcoming junior high and high school reed players with their sax and clarinet playing, continue with the community band, focus on our local community music programs with the Salvation Army (I taught ukulele lessons for 2 years), and stop wasting my time dealing withI've written articles about this over the years, but people don't learn. Hey, who am I to tell them that they shouldn't spend buckets of cash unnecessarily?
I am *not* qualified to recommend mouthpieces to friends although I am constantly called upon to do so. Sometimes I just point to this forum. I mean, I know what works for me but I'm an middle-grade amateur. I will note that many who recommended Rico Metalites to me are *much* strong players that I am. So much so that I bought and tried one. Didn't work for me but doesn't mean that I won't recommend them to the right musicians. YMMV is a very strong ethic in my world. And both you and Helen have ten times the playing experience when compared to me. So when y'all speak, I listen.
And best part, my new Shadow gets to come out and play with me weekly, although I will likely rotate through my tenors a bit just to get them playing in public again. But for the performances, most definitely my Shadow will be my horn of choice.
