Well...
As a major accomplished fact of the Twentieth Century, Nazism is hard to avoid in some shape or form on any wide ranging discussion involving history. So, Mr. Goodwin's "law" is really nothing more than stating that reality usually prevails. Still, it got him on Wikipedia.
(Also, bear in mind that I did not attribute adherence to the Nazi creed (whatever that was - it's quite hard to pin down when you think about it) by any individual, only referring to an artifact that was an exception to the normal saxophonic way of things, in keeping with the topic of this folder. )
And, Nazism, when reflected through the very convoluted mind of Fat Hermann, turns out to be quite a different beast altogether. I have no doubt in my mind that there were Luftwaffe bands with full saxophone sections, simply because the Number 2 man in 1940's Germany was notorious for wanting to have a good time.
(I note here with some pleasure that the Luftwaffe was the first arm of the Wehrmacht that added the bass clarinet to its instrumentation (this in 1939, per The Clarinet, the authoritative history of the horn in German). If the bass clarinet was allowed in Luftwaffe field bands, I submit that anything, even a five horn sax section, was possible.
As a major accomplished fact of the Twentieth Century, Nazism is hard to avoid in some shape or form on any wide ranging discussion involving history. So, Mr. Goodwin's "law" is really nothing more than stating that reality usually prevails. Still, it got him on Wikipedia.
(Also, bear in mind that I did not attribute adherence to the Nazi creed (whatever that was - it's quite hard to pin down when you think about it) by any individual, only referring to an artifact that was an exception to the normal saxophonic way of things, in keeping with the topic of this folder. )
And, Nazism, when reflected through the very convoluted mind of Fat Hermann, turns out to be quite a different beast altogether. I have no doubt in my mind that there were Luftwaffe bands with full saxophone sections, simply because the Number 2 man in 1940's Germany was notorious for wanting to have a good time.
(I note here with some pleasure that the Luftwaffe was the first arm of the Wehrmacht that added the bass clarinet to its instrumentation (this in 1939, per The Clarinet, the authoritative history of the horn in German). If the bass clarinet was allowed in Luftwaffe field bands, I submit that anything, even a five horn sax section, was possible.